Adaption
May 29th, 2007I finished up a trip yesterday, that on day 4 had me flying 6 legs with 3 different captains and 6 different flight attendants. Playing musical FAs isn’t too bad as the interactions between the front crew and the back crew are pretty standardized and not to in depth. The calls to the front or back are made at mostly the same time in the same way and you can generally expect the same answers (2 bags of ice, lav service and potable water). However, adapting to a new captain every few legs can add a bit of stress to a day.
Normally, once you are senior enough to hold a line you will fly with the same captain the whole month unless they have vacation or a training event or drop a trip. Although, due to or chronic short staffing issues it isn’t uncommon to shuffle crews around now even if they are holding a line. For a reservist swapping crews is just part of the game. Ironically enough, it is harder for reserve guys (and I’m talking about FOs only right now) to swap around as they may not be as confident in their own flying abilities yet and to have to adjust to a new (and sometimes demanding) captain can make things hard.
So yesterday I flew with 3 very different captains. My day consisted of Birmingham to Charlotte followed by a Allentown, PA turn, a New Bern turn and then flying home to Dayton. I flew with one captain for the BHM-CLT and CLT-DAY legs, a second captain for the Allentown turn and a third captain for the trip over to New Bern.
Captain 1 is the guy I’ve been flying with all month. he has been here 8 years and has been a captain for 5 of those years. He was a check airman on the Dork but not the jet and drives into Dayton from about an hour away. He is very laid back and safe, although not 100% by the book.
(Let me digress for a minute and talk about flying by the book. The “book” is our operating handbook. It explains the correct way to do everything from start an engine to dealing with an engine failure (or 2) to how to deal with angry passengers. The nice thing about the book (I’m laughing here… anybody seen Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back recently?) is that is allows everybody to be on the same page. You know what is going to happen every step of the way even if you have never flown with somebody before. The book is the standard. Now, all that said, even though the book is the RIGHT way, it isn’t always the most comfortable, fastest, most efficient and safest way of doing thing. Should that matter? Nope, not really. It should still be followed despite all that, but the fact of the matter is that often times it doesn’t. And that isn’t the discussion I am pursuing here today.)
Anyhow, Captain 1 and I have been flying together for 2 months now. We both trust the other guy to do the right thing. I feel comfortable giving him grief about a bad landing (just as he does to me) and I can make a gay joke (he’s gay) and know If I get stuck with a phone call during a quick turn I don’t feel bad that he has to do all the set up work because I know a) he knows I don’t slack off in general and it’s just something that came up on this leg and b) I’ll get the next few for him. We know which buttons and switches I’m going to hit even though they may not be part of the FO flows but I am setting stuff right there anyways (fuel pumps for the first flight of the day fuel check valve check, avionics cooling fan during engine start etc) and if one of us misses a switch the other one will just grab it instead of pointing it out.
Our approach briefs are slightly consolidated (ok, very consolidated) we don’t always wear headsets but every checklist is read fully, special considerations (weather, fuel, maintenance) are always discussed and my opinion is included in the end decision.
All that is pretty normal for a crew that has been flying around together for a while. The benefits of this are huge. Although we haven’t had any emergencies, I know that if we did, I could focus on my duties and not even have to think about what the captain was doing because I know he would be doing it. Likewise he could concentrate on what he had to do because he would now I was doing what I needed to be doing. Now, that said, both of us would probably be keeping an eye peeled to the other side of the cockpit for redundancy’s sake, but I think that is a normal human reaction.
Captain number 2 was a furloughed mainline pilot. He was also a current check airman who routinely does IOE (meaning he teaches “by the book” to new guys) and had been a captain since he came over here 3 years ago. I had to adjust my thinking a little bit. Suddenly everything was standard. We wore headsets through 18000 feet per the book. He hit all the switches he was supposed to even if I was right there (leading to a few UMTs or “uncomfortable man touches”) and every brief was in full and standard. He flew the leg up to ABE and on final I wasn’t sure if he was going to get down in time, although I didn’t say anything, I wasn’t familiar with his descent profile and didn’t know he was going to put the gear out at 210 knots (I normally wait until 180) to slow down. On the way back into Charlotte I was flying and we were slowed from 290 to 250. Normally I would just pull the power back and slow gradually. It’s more comfortable for the passengers and we get to go a little bit faster for just a little bit longer getting there a few seconds earlier. However, not knowing how he wanted things done I went to flight idle and slowed quickly. Would he have said anything if I hadn’t? I don’t know but I didn’t want to take the chance. I sweated out my landing a little bit too as it was the only landing this guy was going to see me make and I my pride wanted it to be a good one. Turns out it was, but if it hadn’t been I would have probably tried to justify it. Captain 2 was a really nice guy. He flew MOSTLY by the book and had a good attitude. Even with all that it was a fair amount of work for me to adjust to his style of cockpit management and procedures.
Captain 3 was flying his last turn before ending his trip. Due to a maintenance problem earlier in the day the flight was running behind and had been downgraded to a 200 from a 700. He has been a captain for 1 year here and been at the company for 6 years. I’d flown with him once before on a turn a few months ago, but didn’t remember too much of it. He seemed very by the book and also very bitter that he was going to be over an hour late getting off his trip and home to his wife of 6 months. After some confusion as to what airplane and what crew was actually doing the New Bern turn we got on the 200 that he had brought back in and boarded up. Of course, there were 70 people trying to go to EWN and we only had 50 seats. They eventually figured out who was going and who wasn’t and we got 50 passengers and a United jump seater. The jump seater complicated stuff a little bit because even though it is the captain’s cockpit people tend to be a little more conservative when there is another set of eyes (especially from another company) on the flight deck.
(Side note: Thank you United Rusty for taking the time to answer all sorts of UAL questions and to offer to answer any future questions either one of us had. You were hands down, one of the most well informed mainline guys I have ever had in a jump seat. Thank you for taking the time to know and understand the regional industry as well as your own mainline world.)
It was my leg over to New Bern and I flew very much by the book (called for all flight control panel changes when I was hand flying, full briefs etc). As it turned out due to traffic at the airport I had to make a quick modification and instead of entering a right downwind I had to fly over the field and make left traffic. It worked out fine though and we managed a 14 minute turn and headed back to Charlotte with Captain 3 at the controls. He was very standard as I had expected, although he lightened up a whole bunch when he saw that he was only going to be about 20 minutes later getting back into Charlotte.
For the final leg up to Dayton I flew with Captain 1 again. We had a little bit of weather to dodge, but other then that it was a non event right up until I forgot I was back in the 700 when flaring out over the numbers and planted it nicely.
So, the moral of the story? I flew with 3 very different captains over the course of the day. Each one set a slightly (or very) different tone on the flight deck. However, because there is a baseline (the book) to start with, I really had no problem adapting to each one’s methods and preferences.